From Beneath the Shroud of Silence: How Tommy Le’s Death Shifts…

Do Nguyen Mai reflects on Tommy Le’s fatal shooting by King’s County police and what it means for Vietnamese America

From Beneath the Shroud of Silence: How Tommy Le’s Death Shifts the Focus for Vietnamese American Political Involvement

Tommy Le was fatally shot by police just hours before graduating from his high school completion program.


Last night, the night before that, and nearly every night between the last and the night of June 30, I have woken at about one o’ clock each morning with a recurring nightmare searing itself onto the insides of my eyelids. In this nightmare, two of my future sons come home to me dead, one from overseas, one from down the street, both with bullets embedded in their bodies. I’ve long held this fear before – the fear that young, Vietnamese American boys like my friends, cousins, and future children would drop lifeless against sidewalk cement following the sound of a gunshot, proving that warzones hungrily follow Vietnamese families regardless of where they settle.

This fear has reissued itself more intensely since I read the news that Tommy Le, a twenty-year-old Vietnamese American man, was shot and killed by King County police on June 14, 2017.

The Seattle Times reports that Tommy Le was fatally shot on June 14 by a King County sheriff’s deputy mere hours before Tommy Le was supposed to graduate from his alternative high-school completion program. Three deputies had been summoned to Tommy Le’s location after nearby homeowners called 911 about a man – later identified as Tommy Le – carrying a sharp, potentially threatening object.

When confronted, Tommy Le reportedly refused commands to drop the sharp object, prompting two deputies to fire their tasers, one of which hit Tommy Le with no effect. A deputy then shot Tommy Le three times. He later died at Harborview Medical Center.

The sharp object that so concerned nearby residents and the responding deputies turned out to be not a knife, but a pen.

Several weeks after Tommy Le’s death, community members gathered for a forum to discuss questions about Le’s death with local officials. According to Seattle Weekly, the discussion included critiques and expressed skepticism about the official police narrative presented about the incident, questioning why King County officials first reported that witnesses said Le brandished a knife when the shots went off before later clarifying that he only had a pen.

Criticism and distrust of the official police narrative surrounding Tommy Le’s death has increased with the release of Tommy Le’s autopsy. The autopsy reveals that Tommy Le was shot twice from behind and was not intoxicated, facts that contradicts and weakens the claim that Tommy Le was involved in direct confrontation with deputies.

Justice for Tommy Le organizer Yenvy Pham is quoted by Seattle Weekly as stating that, when it comes to loud, visible Vietnamese American activism, “it’s just not done.”

Pham’s statement is mostly true. As a community with strong reverence for its elders who, with the fall of the Republic of South Vietnam still in unshakable memory, have traditionally held control of the community’s narrative, there is still strong anti-communist sentiment that understandably pervades the Vietnamese American community, dissuading activities deemed too radical. Protesting the current communist administration of Vietnam is often considered acceptable. Protesting American interference abroad may not be considered as acceptable. Even entertaining concepts such as feminism has, in the past, been labelled too close to a communist activity to be widely accepted, at least by a portion of Vietnamese American elders.

However, as younger Vietnamese American generations move into power within the community and shift the community’s general political focus away from the Vietnam War, it is crucial that the previous, self-inflicted obstacles to significant, lasting political activation not be repeated.

The Vietnamese American community must advocate for itself both within the context of the Asian American community and within the context of the greater American community. It cannot continue to operate and advocate almost solely within its own boundaries and within the context of the Vietnam War. To do so is detrimental to the community’s progress. To do so fixes its collective focus on the past instead of the present. Instead of dwelling on the past, Vietnamese Americans must progress forward. While East Asian Americans and other ethnic groups in the United States continue to advocate for the betterment of their communities, if Vietnamese Americans continue to utilize silence as a safety measure, the community will have its needs buried, ignored, and forgotten.

It is with concern for the desired and anticipated improvement of Vietnamese American lives, especially new and forthcoming ones, that the unwavering, unapologetic political activation of Vietnamese America takes place.

Following the traditional attitudes of subservience and aggressive assimilation is no longer – and arguably never was – an effective safety measure for Vietnamese Americans.

It is increasingly dangerous to pretend that widespread issues that affect other communities do not affect the Vietnamese American community. The data – like that disseminated by projects like AAPI Data – reveal the problems in clear numbers. Poverty affects Vietnamese Americans. Healthcare accessibility affects Vietnamese Americans. Mental health issues affect Vietnamese Americans. Educational barriers affect Vietnamese Americans. Violent policing affects Vietnamese Americans, as it so clearly and fatally did Tommy Le. Neglecting these pervasive issues only provides them increased opportunity to expand and to damage the Vietnamese American community.

Like so many of the young Vietnamese Americans waking from the heavy shroud of silence in the aftermath of Tommy Le’s death, I refuse to have my nightmares turn reality, to have dead sons weighty in my frail arms. The United States should not have to be another warzone for a community forced here by gunfire.

The more time spent engrossed in the past instead of spent concentrating on solving present problems and on building not only a cultural, but a political foundation for the forthcoming Vietnamese American generations, the more time is wasted allowing devastating issues to plague the community – and the more time is spent in mourning for those who paid and will pay for the community’s own prolonged, encouraged political silence with their lives.




Do Nguyen Mai – name written family name to given name – is a Vietnamese American poet, a Southern California native, and an ardent advocate for Vietnamese American progress. She is the founding executive editor of Rambutan Literary and her debut poetry collection, Ghosts Still Walking, is available from Platypus Press.



  1. I share Ms. Do’s concerns for Vietnamese American lives and appreciate her raising this issue. I, too, hope “that the unwavering, unapologetic political activation of Vietnamese America takes place.” Though, I worry how effective political action will be given the racial bias seen in the police’s attitude of killing minorities. Tommy Le’s murder is regrettably one of many Vietnamese Americans unjustifiably killed by police. Given that the Black Lives Matter movement is politically active and constantly in the news, the unjust killings of innocent African Americans continue. The pervasive anti-minority atmosphere by the majority and police seems to me the bigger problem. Nevertheless, I agree we need to “shift the community’s general political focus away from the Vietnam War.” I propose, as a start, we should somehow unite through a central national organization that serves to support the separate Vietnamese communities in their “political activation” efforts. Thank you Ms. Do for your advocacy for Vietnamese American progress.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here